Traditional Literature Three Cinderellas Essay - 916 Words

Most people are familiar with the Cinderella story as told in the translation by Marcia Brown. There are also cultural and parodied versions of this tale. For a cultural version, I will be referring to Sootface, an Ojibwa tale retold by Robert D. San Souci and illustrated by Daniel San Souci (San Souci, 1994). The parody Ive chosen is Cinderumpelstiltskin, found in the book The Stinky Cheese Man and Other Fairly Stupid Tales, by Jon Scieszka and illustrated by Lane Smith (Scieszka, 1992). All three renditions are picture storybooks, and have similarities in the cast of characters and in the motifs of transformation and magic, but there are significant differences within those similar themes. The three stories have honored†¦show more content†¦We can tell by looking at the illustration alone that this is no ordinary retelling of the Cinderella story. A young woman in distress is the common main character, and there are similarities and slight differences in the womans fa mily, and in the prince figure, as well. The Cinderella figure portrayed by Brown and Scieszka are already beautiful. Poor Sootfaces beauty has been scarred by ashes from the fire; her hair is singed. In all three renditions, the mother of the Cinderella figure has died. Both Browns and Scieszkas Cinderellas have wicked stepmothers and mean stepsisters. Sootface has no stepmother; its her mean sisters that mock her and make her do their work. The father figures are either absent or powerless to help Cinderellas situation. The father of Browns Cinderella is tied hand and foot to his wifes apron strings. Sootfaces father seems to be off hunting while Sootface is abused at the hands of her sisters. And Scieszka doesnt even mention Cinderellas father. The prince (or mighty warrior, in Sootface) does appear in all three stories. All the young women in Browns Cinderella and San Soucis Sootface want to be betrothed to this character; in Cinderumpelstiltskin, he is just mentioned as the host of the ball. Despite the differences in settings and familyShow MoreRelatedCinderella Stories1524 Words   |  7 PagesCinderella Stories Lesson Plan Sherryl Green Grand Canyon University: RDG:585 October 8, 2012 Lesson Plan Cinderella Stories ABSTRACT In this study of Cinderella Stories, second grade students will use charts and diagrams to discover the similarities and differences among stories. Students will develop writing skills using descriptive language and details. They will strengthen their comprehension skills through the use of magical Cinderella tales from different lands and apply map skillsRead MoreHow Traditional Literature Has Changed Over Time894 Words   |  4 Pagesthere were varying topics, but they were all under one category, which was traditional children’s literature. In the book many topics are discussed which include, what it means for a book to be traditional literature, how traditional literature has changed over time, the categories in which the different books can fall under, the different cultures and countries that the stories come from, the elements within traditional literature, and lastly the hero circle. There were also several articles that I readRead MoreThe Disney Princesses85 7 Words   |  3 Pagesgiven characteristics that are very gender specific. The next Disney Princess to be released was Cinderella in 1950 followed by Sleeping Beauty in 1959. These films also conformed to the conventional beliefs about women and their place in society. These princesses both had very soft-spoken voices that were barely audible (Whelan, 23). In Cinderella it also displays her doing the stereotypically traditional tasks of cleaning and looking after the house. She accepted without complaint all the tasks herRead MoreGender Stereotypes : Masculinity And Femininity1195 Words   |  5 Pagessame-sex relations, which the US has not fully recognized yet. The Hijars in India are homosexual or intersex males who embody aspects of the traditional female gender role. They dress as women do and can marry husbands if they so choose. Or the Albanians in southwest Europe and northern Greece are biological females that take a vow of chastity, and embody traditional male gender roles. They do this for multiple reasons because they always felt more male, to avoid marriage, and/or to access the power andRead MoreCinderella vs Ella Enchanted Essay2614 Words   |  11 PagesCinderella vs Ella Enchanted The tale of Cinderella has been heard and read for many generations. The idea of rags to riches has appealed to countless readers through varying accounts. The plot of Cinderella has become a traditional theme. Through different cultures and eras the theme has seen many copies, remakes, twists and views in literature, theater and film. Today’s era of blended families and conflicts in class statuses may be why Cinderella has been a classic. One of those twists is seenRead MoreThe Girl Against The Brick Essay2140 Words   |  9 Pageseveryone around them. Weeks pass, the students never came to the pub. Then, after three months, I saw the familiar faces. There was a weakness among them, some even sitting in silence. I looked to the brick wall where Elizabeth always stood, but the wall was empty. In fact, from that weekend on, I never saw Elizabeth again. Recipe A dark twist on a classic take on ignored abuse. Serving Size: One Cooking Time: Three to Six weeks depending on the severity relationship Recipe Difficulty: Very DifficultRead MoreAnalysis Of Disney Princess Films848 Words   |  4 Pagesportrayal of Disney princesses is the stereotypical damsel-in-distress, and very domestic. This can be seen through Snow White, Cinderella, and Sleeping Beauty. A second portrayal arose and shifted the roles of female characters to be seen as independent and free spirited. This picture can be seen through characters of Merida, Anna and Elsa. Through different researches and literature reviews, including the movies themselves, Disney can be seen slowly making strides along with the surrounding culture andRead MoreFairytales : The Way Of The Society And Mainstream Pop Culture1457 Words   |  6 Pageswomen are inferior to men. Traditional gender role stereotypes in fairytales negatively impact young children. Stereotypes are a widely held but fixed and oversimplified image or idea of a particular type of person or thing. Some widely known stereotypes about gender are women are compassionate, cook and clean, and dependent. Men are strong, they are not emotional, and are in charge. The list goes on and on. While on the hand there are traditional gender roles. Traditional gender roles are the publicRead MoreThe Body of the Disney Princesses1568 Words   |  6 PagesPrincesses have always been a form of innocence for young girls. However, while it’s clear that the majority of people adore the Disney Princesses, still, most can see the impact it can produce on young girls that will follow them into adulthood. Literature Review According to various articles, although the Disney Princesses seem to be an innocent form of entertainment for young girls, their overall messages serve as a negative influence on how they develop into adults. This is where the unrealisticRead MoreCompare/Contrast the Treatment of Femininity in Pygmalion and Medea1437 Words   |  6 PagesHistorically, the treatment of femininity in literature is wide ranging. Some texts explore the feelings and responsibilities involved with typically feminine traits such as motherhood and in social environments, while others highlight more feminist issues such as the struggle for equality and male oppression. Authors of both sexes have made major contributions to this area in literature but it remains surprising that male writers have been able to perceptively portray women above their previously